The Mirror of Knowledge

The Mirror of Knowledge

Unity of Reality and Differentiated Epistemic Competences: Reconstructing a Model for Adjudicating Science–Religion Relations

Document Type : Scientific-research

Authors
1 Ph.D. Candidate in Teaching Theoretical Foundations of Islam, Faculty of Islamic Teachings and Thought, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
2 Fourth-level student at Qom Seminary, senior student at Zanjan University, Islamic theology and philosophy
3 Faculty and Associate Professor at Shahid Beheshti University, Department of History of Islamic Civilization and Political Jurisprudence, Dean of the Faculty of Theology and Religions.
Abstract
This study reconstructs a model for adjudicating science–religion relations whose units of analysis are claims, methods, values, and institutions rather than two homogeneous domains. It asks how a minimally unified reality can be combined with methodological plurality and the fallibility of human understanding, and how later audiences can assess claims attributed to revelation. The method combines conceptual analysis, normative reconstruction, comparison with the closest rivals, and a case study. The model rests on constrained methodological pluralism and the principles of non-substitution and asymmetric competences. It distinguishes the event of revelation, prophetic reception and proclamation, transmission of a carrier, and later interpretation. Applying an eight-stage protocol to brain death separates medical agreement about neurological status from philosophical and juristic disagreement about death and from conditional legal-institutional authorization. The contribution is reconstructive, combinatorial, and operational: the model identifies the locus of disagreement, bridge premises, responsible epistemic agents, and stopping points without claiming general superiority or representing a single Islamic position.
Keywords


Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 23 September 2026